nature vs nurture

Cards (21)

  • nature 

    behaviour is caused by genetic factors
  • nurture 

    behaviour is a product of past experiences and upbringing
  • nativists
    people who adopt an extreme hereditary position that believe individual differences are due to each persons unique genetic code
  • nurturists
    people who believe that at birth the human mind is a blank slate that is gradually filled as a result of experiences
  • example of the nature debate
    the biological approach
  • example of the nurture debate
    the behaviourist approach
  • child development - nature
    Chomsky said humans are born with innate biological capacity to learn language known as language acquisition
  • child development - nurture
    skinner used operant conditioning where behaviours are learned through rewards or punishment
  • personality development - nature
    Bouchard studied twins where they tend to have more similar personalities then a fraternal twins indicating a genetic component to personality
  • personality development - nurture
    Caspi suggested whilst some personality traits show continuity from childhood, they also change and develop significantly rather than becoming fixed in early life
  • mental illness development - nature
    Keller said the concept of mental illness development is generally understood to arise from the complex interplay of genetic and environmental factors
  • mental illness development - nurture
    Sullivan believed mental illness stems from interpersonal failures, where a persons inability to adapt to social demands leads to dysfunction
  • intelligence - nature
    Plomin and Spinath highlights the increasing heritability of intelligence with age and the shared genetic influences across different cognitive abilities
  • intelligence- nurture
    Flynn showed average IQ scores have increased over generations, suggesting environmental improvements knows as the Flynn effect can lead to substantial gains in cognitive ability
  • the interactionist approach
    the idea that both nature and nurture play a role in the development of mental disorders
  • Piaget - child development stages
    children progress through biologically based, universal cognitive stages that indicate an inherent genetically programmed unfolding of cognitive abilities
  • Gottesman and Shields - twin schizophrenia
    carried out a meta analysis of European twin studies where there was a 48% concordance rate of schizophrenia in MZ twins and a 17% concordance rate in DZ twins
  • Maguire et al. - taxi drivers
    taxi drivers had more grey matter on the posterior hippocampi then non taxi drivers, a correlational analysis showed a positive volume of posterior hippocampi grey matter and length of time spent as a taxi driver
  • Tienari - finnish adoptive family study
    child rearing style characterised by high levels of criticism and low levels of empathy was implicated in the development of schizophrenia in children with high genetic risk
  • Watson - little albert
    little albert was classically conditioned to have a fear of rats which he then associated to any animal with fur
  • Bandura - Bobo doll
    the children copy the behaviour they see their parents do as it’s part of their upbringing to imitate them