Studies carried out on non-human species, for ethical or practical reasons
Lorenz's Geese: Procedure
Randomly divided a clutch of goose eggs, where half hatched naturally with their mother, and half hatched in an incubator where the first thing they saw was Lorenz.
Lorenz's Geese: Findings
The goslings would follow Lorenz (or the mother goose) because of imprinting, even when mixed with the other group. He identified a 'criticalperiod' where the first attachment must be made.
Sexual imprinting
relationship between imprinting and adult mate preferences
Lorenz's geese: Weakness
Difficult to generalise birds to humans, as mammals show more attachment to their young.
Lorenz's geese: Weakness
Guiton et al observed a chicken imprinting on a rubber glove and try mate with it, but learning to mate with other chickens. Lorenz says imprinting is permenant, but this research proves otherwise.
Harlow's monkeys: Procedure
16 baby rhesus monkey's raised with either a wirefood-dispensing mother, a clothfood-dispensing mother, or a plain cloth mother.
Harlow's monkeys: Findings
The monkeys always preferred the cloth mother over the wire mother, regardless if they got food. Shows that comfort is more important than food.
Harlow's monkeys: Strength
The research has had a positive effect on psychologist's understanding of human-infant attachment, by showing that closecontact enables attachment and helping analyse attachments between mother and infant.
Harlow's Monkeys: Weakness
There are major ethical issues as the monkeys faced lots of suffering, which Harlow was aware of as he named the isolation tanks the 'pits of despair'