Kant's ideas on ethics based on reason, goodwill, and duty
Kant's ideas
Humans can be ethical without relying on religion
Emphasis on reason, goodwill, and duty in ethical living
Autonomous reason
The foundation of ethics according to Kant
Goodwill
Doing what you know is right because it's achievable, not because you have to
Goodwill in action
Helping a classmate with homework because you genuinely want to see them succeed, not because you expect something in return
Duty
What reason determines as our obligation, and it motivates our actions
Duty in action
Standing up for someone being bullied because you believe it's wrong to see someone suffer unfairly
Obligation and autonomy
Duty is something we choose to do because we know it's right, not because of outside pressure
Each person is responsible for their own actions and decisions
Our duty should be universalizable, meaning it's something everyone should do in similar situations
Kant's ethics are independent of religion but open to hope
Kant's ethics provide a rational basis for moral behavior without relying on faith
Utilitarianism
A theory that addresses how to judge the morality of actions based on their consequences
John Stuart Mill's utilitarianism
Focuses on promoting the greatest happiness for the greatest number
Happiness is defined as pleasure and the absence of pain
The Greatest Happiness Principle is the ultimate measure of morality
Quality vs. quantity of pleasures
Mill distinguishes between higher and lower pleasures
Some pleasures, like those of the intellect, are considered higher
Utilitarianism considers both the quantity and quality of happiness
Higher pleasures
Studying for three hours a day can lead to long-term benefits
Playing online games provides immediate gratification but may lack lasting fulfillment
Some argue that happiness is unattainable, but Mill sees it as achievable through a balance of pleasures
Utilitarianism is accused of ignoring self-sacrifice, but Mill believes it's acceptable when it benefits the majority
Critics question whether people always act with society in mind, but Mill focuses on the consequences of actions
The ultimate sanction
Mill discusses external and internal sanctions for moral conduct
Fear of displeasing God or society may influence behavior, but conscience is the ultimate guide
A clear conscience comes from considering the welfare of others in decision-making
Utilitarianism aims to promote happiness for the greatest number
Mill emphasizes considering both the quantity and quality of happiness
Moral actions contribute to the well-being of the community, guided by conscience
Kant's ethics
Humans can be ethical without relying on religion
Kant's ethics
Emphasize the importance of reason, goodwill, and duty in ethical living
Autonomous reason
The foundation of ethics
Goodwill
Doing what you know is right because it's achievable, doing good things because you want to, not because you have to
Goodwill in action
Offering to help your classmate with their homework because you genuinely want to see them succeed, not because you expect something in return
Duty
What reason determines as our obligation, and it motivates our actions, what we should do because our reason tells us it's right
Duty in action
Standing up for someone being bullied at school because you believe it's wrong to see someone suffer unfairly
Obligation and autonomy
Duty is something we choose to do because we know it's right, not because of outside pressure, each person is responsible for their own actions and decisions, our duty should be universalizable
Kantian ethics and religion
Kant's ethics are independent of religion but open to hope, happiness isn't the goal of ethics for Kant, but it's related to living justly, religion complements ethics by offering hope for happiness beyond our efforts
Kant's ethics provide a rational basis for moral behavior without relying on faith
Kant's ideas focus on duty, reason, and autonomy, which are important for ethical decision-making
Human decisions have consequences that affect others
Decisions create new ideas, objects, and relationships
Morality
Judged based on motives and consequences
Utilitarianism
Addresses how to judge the morality of actions
Mill's utilitarianism
Focuses on promoting the greatest happiness for the greatest number, happiness is defined as pleasure and the absence of pain, the Greatest Happiness Principle is the ultimate measure of morality
Quality vs. quantity of pleasures
Mill distinguishes between higher and lower pleasures, some pleasures, like those of the intellect, are considered higher, utilitarianism considers both the quantity and quality of happiness
Higher pleasures
Studying for three hours a day can lead to long-term benefits, playing online games provides immediate gratification but may lack lasting fulfillment
Some argue that happiness is unattainable, but Mill sees it as achievable through a balance of pleasures