Worked as a carer for nearly 12 years, much longer than most of the students she grew up with at Hailsham
Has outlived most of her childhood friends
Spends her days looking backwards, recalling her memories of the people she has lost
Kathy's memories
Trace her complex relationships with her Hailsham friends Tommy and Ruth
Kathy's reflections preserve the memory of Tommy and Ruth, both of whom have already "completed"
Unreliable narrator
Kathy's account is subjective, presenting events from only her point of view
She does not recall events in strict chronological order, frequently interrupting one memory to share a related memory from another period in her life
She often states that she may be misremembering certain details
She admits that Tommy or Ruth recalled a particular event or conversation differently than she does
These idiosyncrasies reflect the unreliability of memory itself, which is necessarily incomplete and episodic
Kathy is also an unreliable narrator because she carefully guards her own feelings
Kathy never explicitly states the depths of her feelings for Tommy, although her love becomes increasingly clear as the narrative unfolds
Kathy
Reliance on silence and indirection, especially when it comes to expressing her emotions
Often expresses her anger with Ruth by walking away rather than explicitly confronting her
As a student at Hailsham, exhibits restraint and self-consciousness, often worrying about being seen or overheard, especially in conversation with Tommy
Kathy frames herself as a careful observer, often standing outside the action in her memories, carefully watching those around her and noticing subtle details about their behavior
At the Cottages, Kathy realizes that many of the veteran couples have copied their gestures of affection from television
Ruth
Kathy's close childhood friend
Ruth's relationship with Kathy
1. Lives with Kathy at Hailsham and the Cottages
2. Becomes Kathy's carer when Ruth is a donor
Ruth at Hailsham
Outspoken and hot-tempered
Natural leader among her friends
Often highly controlling
Ruth and Kathy
Foils to each other's personalities
Argue frequently
Use subtle hints and indirection rather than direct confrontation
Ruth's romantic relationship
Longstanding with Tommy
Ruth's romantic relationship with Tommy
Underlying and unspoken source of tension in her friendship with Kathy, who has romantic feelings for Tommy as well
Ruth's make-believe games at Hailsham
1. Leads friends in games
2. Elaborate invention of "secret guard" to protect Miss Geraldine
Ruth's pretending at Hailsham
Implies special knowledge and privileges unavailable to other students
Reflects her longing for affection from a caring adult
Ruth's "dream future" and "possible" at the Cottages
Pins her hopes on the vague story of a person who resembles her and from whose DNA she may have been cloned, in Norfolk
Ruth's treatment of Tommy and Kathy
Can be capricious and unkind, often ignores and mocks them
But also has capacity for deep generosity and thoughtfulness
Ruth's generosity towards Kathy
Marshals classmates to search for Kathy's lost Judy Bridgewater tape at Hailsham
Gifts Kathy a different tape as a substitute
Ruth's gift to Kathy and Tommy
Offers them Madame's address, believing they still have a chance to ask for a deferral on their donations
Ruth's gift of Madame's address
Demonstrates her sincere desire to make amends for keeping Kathy and Tommy apart
Tommy
Kathy's close childhood friend, for whom she also harbors romantic feelings
Tommy at Hailsham
Becomes an outcast among his peers because he lacks artistic ability
Develops a violent temper, often throwing tantrums in response to teasing from his peers
Tommy as a young adult
Remains anxious and self-conscious about his artistic abilities
Initially keeps his artwork a secret at the Cottages
Begins to derive pride and personal satisfaction from drawing
His compelling imaginary animals resist interpretation, reflecting the deep humanity and complex individuality of the clones themselves
Tommy
More straightforward than Kathy and Ruth, often missing the subtle digs and sarcasm that they shoot back and forth
Kathy
Often knowingly defends Ruth's pretenses in front of others
Tommy
Usually expresses his confusion or doubt aloud
Lacks the kind of emotional restraint that Kathy and Ruth exhibit
Prone to violent temper tantrums
Tommy's relationships with Ruth and Kathy
Maintains a longstanding but difficult romantic relationship with Ruth, who at times belittles and ignores him
Bonds with Kathy over their mutual desire to discover the truth about Hailsham
Tends to trust Kathy with his biggest secrets, including his odd conversations with Miss Lucy
In his theorizing with Kathy, shows an observant and reflective side to his personality that mirrors her own
Miss Lucy
A guardian at Hailsham during Kathy's childhood
Miss Lucy
Comes across as gruff, but cares deeply about the children
Gives Kathy her first clues that life outside of Hailsham is much harsher than the students know
As a child, Kathy does not readily understand Miss Lucy's hints about the outside world
But Kathy connects the dots as she reminisces about her life
Miss Lucy's belief
Hailsham should teach the students a comprehensive understanding of why they exist and what their lives will look like when they go out to become donors
Miss Lucy believes the students deserve to know the truth
Because it is their lives at stake
Although Miss Lucy and the students can do nothing to change their futures, Miss Lucy feels it is wrong they should have only a polite and polished impression of their own lives
Miss Lucy strategically chooses her moments to talk to the students about their futures so that Miss Emily and the other guardians are not present to interfere
Miss Lucy's speech in the pavilion
Reflects her ongoing struggle with her role as a guardian
Provides the students with an unusually straightforward account of the donation program
Miss Emily explains Miss Lucy's ideology was not welcome at Hailsham
Miss Lucy's method was too idealistic for the real world