Introduced the idea of "male as norm" - women are extension of men e.g Mr and Mrs
Parker et al
commenting and women's sexual behaviours is designed to damage her social status and cause negative psychological effects
Stanley
There are 220 negative terms to describe promiscuous women but only 20 to describe men. Gender disparity in society between men and women's behaviour
Holmes
Women are often referred to as food and animals e.g cow+sugar
O'barrandAtkins
identified that menusedeficitlanguage that Lakoff coined and identified. This proves it is notjustgender that defineslanguage it is alsocontext and topic which are driving force.
Jesperson
women'slanguage is littered with non-fluency features because they speak before thinking. But this is only based on public perception and is not proven.
ESRC
Found that women use the word "fuck" 50 times more than they did before 1990s - this shows limitations put on women have changed over time. Therefore they can adopt "male assumed" language without reprise.
Who made the deficitmodel?
Lakoff
What is the deficitmodel?
suggest women's language is weaker
women's language reflects women's subordinate position in society
Their language makes them inherently weak
What makes women language disadvantaged according to Lakoff?
Lack of assertiveness, hesitation, tag questions
weak adjectives
'nice' women do not use strong and bold adjectives when describing
affective adjectives
adjectives that describe feelings or emotional responses to things, for example 'a charming house'
back changeling
women passively agree and support conversation when talking -'yeah' and 'ummhum'
emphatic stress
using explicit, exaggerated pitch or volume
hedges
Phrases such as 'you know' or 'sort of' that can be seen to make an utterance most tentative
precise colour terms
a greater range of hyponyms within a particular colour e.g scarlet, vermillion, burgundy
rising intonation
adding a rise in pitch at the end of a utterance making its effect more like a question
super polite forms
the use of euphemisms and lack of words considered to be swearing or taboo
tag question
the addition of short phrases like 'do you' to the end of a sentence
intensifier/degree modifiers
use the words 'so', 'very', 'really'. Using so to add strength to a word 'so weird'
Vocabulary or women's work language
used to describe typically carried out by women
weakness of deficit
creating a dichotomy between men and women's language.
using men's language as the benchmark to compare women's language against
men's language is powerful to the detriment of women
men's language suppresses women's language
when was the deficit model made?
1975
who made the dominance model?
zimmerman and west
what is suggested in the dominance model?
men are always more dominant in conversations
what happens in the dominance model?
men interrupted 96%
women interrupted 4%
overlapping and interruptions happening
overlap
this is when the listener interrupts the speaker during a conversation but the speaker continues to speak. Resulting in two speakers talking at the same time, meaning there are only speakers not listeners.
competitiveoverlap
hindersconversation by disruptingturntaking and cause a fightfordominance
cooperative overlap
listener becomes a speaker to show interest and agreement/support. The overlapping shows they are listening
interruption
listener breaks in to interjects while a speaking. The speaker then stops talking.
competitive interruption
listener forcefully interjects and continues talking. ( disregards for the other speakers turn)
cooperative interruption
helpgul remarks or to add (questions/reassurance/remarks)
what is semantic derogation?
Semantic derogation is the process by which a word's meaning becomes more negative over time.
This is normally refers to language when women are prejudiced against
primary creators of most of them are men
How does age play into semantic degradation?
older women = unattractive and have a bad temper
words about women that are not hot = clingy and overweight
overweight = old, worn out, useless animal
animals = horses and cows = old women
what is demographic levelling?
least offensive form from a high rank to coo
words have changed from high rank to common standing
This may not be offensive or abusive but women are not seen as fit to hold positions of power
what is feminism?
the advocacy of women's rights on the basis of equality of equality of the sexes
how does power dynamic effect language?
men has power in every conversation
Muriel Schulz
negative meaning/connatation that some lexical items have.
e.g have had nice/ good meanings towards women, have now turned to rude and slanderous
Judith butler (1990)
language is used to project on identity rather than reinforce gender stereotypes
we conform to norm as it is not biologically constructed
your gender is constructed through repetitive performances of gender
gender identity is fluid and we identify beyond gender
Janet Hyde (2005)
males and females are more alike than not with personality ability, and leadership
differences is the context that it is measured in
males and females are more a like than not but not all psychological variables