Parenting errors of commission. Threatening input into the system
Neglect
Parenting errors of omission. Lack of input into the system
Physical abuse
Intentional use of physical force against a child that can result in injury
Sexual abuse
Any attempted or completed sexual act, exploitation of a child by a caregiver
Emotional abuse
Intentional behavior that conveys to a child they are worthless
To make a diagnosis and suggest course of treatment
Medical definition
Diagnostic categories reflecting maltreatment: non-accidental trauma, failure to thrive
To protect children and optimize development through intervention
Social services
Spectrums of parenting behavior and child outcomes rather than categories
To make decisions about parental rights and child advocacy
Legal definition
Often open to interpretation
To better understand the phenomenon
Research definition
Inherent link to measurement
More attention to other factors like environment, developmental theory, severity, chronicity, etc
Unsubstantiated
Unfounded, not indicated
Substantiated
Services related to family preservation, protection, out of home placement
Present people with descriptions of a case and vary particular pieces of information
Vignette studies
Help us examine questions related to definitional issues
How do details about the case influence one's characterization of maltreatment?
How does the background of the assessor influence one's characterization of maltreatment?
What affects our judgment?
Factors that affect our judgment
Parental characteristics
Intent and demographics
Professional background of the assessor
Parental intent
Willfully inflicted act vs parental ignorance
In the presence of severe injuries Turbett and O'toole found that black children are nearly twice as likely to be seen as victims
Similar findings with socioeconomic findings
Other more recent studies like Hansen have not replicated these findings
Ards et al: Picture of black and white baby in same room (messy, etc)
More people would say that the black baby met the state's definition of neglect, regardless of the race of the participant
Background of the assessor
Social workers and police rate incidents as most severe
Lawyers rate incidents as less severe
Pediatricians generally fall in the middle
We lack universal definitions
Definitions may be biased by characteristics of the case beyond specific incidents of maltreatment
Definitions may be biased by professional and personal background
Sources of info for measurement
CPS records
Self-report
Observation
Dimensions to assess
Type
Frequency
Chronicity
Severity
Best approach is multi method, multi sourced
Challenges of research: Measurement, Testing Causation, Confounds
Structural changes: changes in how the brain is structured or built, such as the volume/size of different brain regions or number of connections between regions
Functional changes: Changes in how the brain functions to complete tasks, we can look at patterns of activation and measures of efficiency
Deficits in emotion processing
Higher internalizing problems
Perceptual biases for threatening information
In general, there is not enough evidence to convey that abuse and neglect affects the size of the amygdala
There is strong evidence that institutional care results in significant changes to the amygdala