How do we know that water cycles through the HTV?
1. The heat loss through the theoretical cooling of lava by conduction is larger than the heat loss measured at hydrothermal vents
2. So water must help cool the lava
3. There was also a missing sink for Mg2+, and the the input did not = the output, implying that there was a sink between the saltwater-basalt interaction inside the hydrothermal vents