How did Wolsey serve King well with the Act of Resumption 1515?
returned land lost by the Crown to the nobility in previous civil wars
increased crown income & assets
How did Wolsey serve King badly with Act of Resumption 1515?
it was bitterly opposed by some of the nobility
How did Wolsey serve King well with Subsidy tax 1513 & 1523?
to work alongside fifteenth and tenths which didn't represent true distribution of wealth, nor had been revised in line w inflation
the Subsidy was a flexible, fairer tax system - the greater your wealth, the more you pay
W raised £325,000 by this new tax (1514-29)
How did Wolsey serve King badly with subsidy tax?
1523 parl saw serious arguments about level of taxation needed to pay for war against Fr - refused Wolsey to levy the tax at rate of 4 shillings for every pound & only allowed him rate 2 shillings in the pound
wolsey had asked parl for taxes worth £800,000 but had to settle for £200,000
How did Wolsey serve King well with forced loans?
introduced form of forced loans on nobility, towns & regions in 1522-23 to raise extra funds for war
raised around £240,000 for crown
How did Wolsey serve King badly with forced loans?
very unpopular - those forced to lend money understood they may never get it paid back
amount raised was insufficient to pay for new French war
What was the Amicable Grant?
In 1525 following the Battle of Pavia where the French King Francis had been captured, Henry sought the funds to launch a new third invasion of France
How did Wolsey serve King well with the Amicable Grant 1525?
took blame for its unpopularity despite it being Henry's idea - shielding the King & gov
How did Wolsey serve King badly with the Amicable Grant 1525?
very unpopular - tax rate too high, 1523 Subsidy still being collected & Forced Loans had not been repaid
people resented a tax for a new war since money paid to fund 1523 invasion of France been wasted when invasion failed
In Suffolk 10,000 rebels revolted against amicable grant, whilst unrest simmered elsewhere
tax rapidly abandoned but left Wolsey's reputation permanently tarnished & many people bitter (inc parliament who Wolsey had tried to bypass)
How did Wolsey serve King well with his personal wealth?
wealth as a 'servant' reflected well on King himself
court of 400-500 people helped Cardinal impress foreign visitors - also be used to awe domestic rivals, ensuring stability in the kingdom
How did Wolsey serve King badly with his personal wealth?
Was richest person in the country (10x income of nearest rival)
had highest level of purchasing power of anyone in history of eng
but no apparent need for wealth - made him a target for opponents
dubious - money made from posts held, fees levied on church court cases & 'gifts'. Prepared to steal e.g. plundered estates of the dead Earl of Derby, which he was 'looking after' until Earl's heir turned 18
4 ways Wolsey impacted order & administration
centralisation of power
Eltham Ordinances 1526
Relations w parliament
Relations w nobility
Wolsey's centralisation of power - positives
achieved PapalLegate status in 1518 (temporarily) & then permanently in 1524 - now had near complete control over English church - effectively gave King control over much of the Church & led to centralising of power in the crown
e.g. Kings control shown when Wolsey bowed to Henry's will to appoint Henry Standish as Bishop of Asaph in 1518 instead of his own preferred candidate
Strengthened the Crown's power by appointing Justices of Peace to decide on legal matters in English counties - reducing power of localnobles
Eltham Ordinances 1526 - Wolsey positives
attempt to repair the chaotic finances of the Royal Household
unnecessary jobs eliminated - e.g. 12 Gentlemen of Privy chamber cut to 6
access to King to be reduced
those paid to perform household duties would no longer be able to delegate work to others
hangers-on were expelled from court
appoints now to be based on merit
measures made sound financial sense
Eltham Ordinances 1526 - Wolsey negatives
reality was they were a series of measures by Wolsey to gain more power
by reducing Gentlemen of the PrivyChamber he could reduce noble's access to Henry & remove specific opponents like Sir WilliamCrompton, Groom of the Stool, and Thomas & George Boleyn (Anne's brothers) - caused much resentment
once rivals removed W soon lost interest in Ordinaces & reform of gov as whole - suggest they were introduced solely for self-interest
what's more, most of those W sought to exclude soon worked their way back into court
Wolsey good relations with Parliament
parl of 1523 considered success (according to Peter Gwyn) since large amount of money raised by the Subsidy (£150,000-£200,000) and 15 new laws were passed
Gwynn also argues Wolsey had no need to call parl 1515-23 since eng was at peace & because since it had been so generous in granting Crown new taxes 1513-15 Wolsey had no urgent need to seek extra funds
Wolsey's bad relations with Parliament
was arrogant and expected parl to agree to all of his & Henry's policies
therefore became indignant when they 'caused trouble' as in 1515 criticised when they Church e.g. Hunne Case where church accused of murder
arrogance = failed to work well w parl & angered MPs - by asking for too much money for wars and for attempting to introduce the non-parliament approved Amicable Grant tax
Didn't summon parl 1515-23 - instead ran country without their 'advice' - some argue was because he'd made an enemy of parl
Wolsey's good relations with the nobility
relationship generally considered to be one of mutual toleration & co-operation (at least while eng prospered)
W didn't wish to 'break' nobility, merely bend it to will of king
Henry was the harsh, untrusting one, not Wolsey- e.g. Wolsey had tried to warn the Duke of Buckingham as to his dangerous behaviour & had little involvement in his arrest, trial and execution - was largely work of Henry's paranoia, not W's malice
Wolsey's bad relations with the nobility
W's unpopularity led him to be blamed for Duke of Buckingham's execution e.g. by Duke's son
any resentment nobility held towards Chief Minsiter potentially threatened good government & stability of the realm
nobility always retained a degree of hostility towards this 'low born' cleric who'd made himself so rich & powerful
nobles like Lord Howard, Duke of Norfolk and Charles Brandon, Duke of Suffolk, played role in W's downfall
his partially pro-French foreign policy angered many nobles who saw French as natural enemy
3 courts under Wolsey
Court of the Star Chamber
Court of Chancery
Court of Requests
Court of the Star Chamber - positives
used to root out cases of perjury & contempt of court amongst the nobility - proving no one was above the law
e.g. 1516 Henry Percy Earl of Northumberland was imprisoned for contempt of court whilst Lord Hastings & Lord Burgavenny were prosecuted for keeping retainers - strengthen Crown's authority
Wolsey sat several times a week so court dealt with 10x the amount of cases it had done before he became Lord Chancellor
Court of the Star Chamber - negatives
Wolsey's prosecution of nobility made him rich & powerful enemies
some believed he was less interested in justice & more in conducting vendetta against upper classes, since they looked down on his own low-birth
Court of Requests - successes
grew in popularity under Wolsey
ordinary people, esp the poor and women, were able to get their legal cases heard more quickly & cheaply than under ordinary common law courts
Court of Chancery - successes
handled matters such as wills, property disputes, contracts etc
could overturn or regulate common law court decisions if deemed unfair
Wolsey increased the Court's workload & created a number of important legal judgements (precedents) which shaped aspects of English law for generates - creating important legacy
Court of Chancery & Court of Requests - failures
were huge problems w common law courts at this time so ordinary people's access to justice in this period was limited
Wolsey's increasing of the workload merely tinkered with a legal system that required a much more fundamental overhaul - reforms did not go nearly far enough
General Wolsey successes in order & administration
had genuine interest in law & justice
took pleasure in ensuring rights of ordinary men & women were maintained against the rich & powerful - Wolsey often favoured poor & often waved the legal fees they owed him
tried to fix prices to prevent exploitation e.g. 1518 introducing the 'Just Price' mechanisms to control the price of meat in cities
General Wolsey failures in order & administration
quite happy to trample poor people's rights when it suited him e.g. in land disputes w his own properties
used legal system as means of exercising control. Used it for revenge e.g. Sir AmyasPaulet had humiliated him in past so he forced Paulet to have to appear before the courts every day for 5 years, on pain of losing all his property. Also had MP Robert Sheffield imprisoned on unjust charge of compliance to murder in revenge for speaking out against Church in 1515 parliament
Enclosures - Wolsey success
made some efforts to stop greedy landowners enclosing common land
1517 he launched a nationwide investigation into enclosed land & successfully prosecuted 220 landowners out of 260 charged w illegal enclosure - proof of desire to tackle situation
Enclosures - Wolsey failures
failed to stop the practice of enclosure - tackling instead in a piecemeal manner
largely abandoned anti-enclosure in 1523 in a deal with Parliament (made up of landowners) in return for their voting taxes for Henry's Second French War
some speculated he opposed enclosures, not to help poor, but to spite the rich nobles & gentry who looked down on him because of his low-birth
3 main areas of Wolsey's impact on spiritual matters (control & management of the church)
Wolsey's control over the Church & treatment of the Pope
Wolsey's jobs & abuses of the church
Church reforms, tackling heresy & the dissolution of 30 minor monasteries
Wolsey's control over Church & treatment of the Pope - failures
blocked Pope's attempts to create a general European peace treaty & crusade against the Ottoman Empire in 1518 until he’d been appointed a temporary Legate. Then he hijacked the plan and organised a European peace deal himself - England gained all the prestige, whilst the crusade idea was dumped
once he gained permanent Legate positon he largely ignored Pope - cost him later when he unsuccessfully asked Pope to grant Henry divorce
Wolsey's control over the Church & treatment of the Pope - successes
Wolsey was loyal to the king, not the Pope
acquired so many church positions for himself & supporters (1523 controlled 13 of 23 English & Welsh bishoprics) that he gained clear control over Church - power of Popereduced, power of monarchyincreased
Papal Legate status 1524- now had near complete control over English church - gave King control over much of the Church - e.g. Wolsey bowed to Henry's will to appoint Henry Standish as Bishop of Asaph in 1518 instead of his own preferred candidate
Wolsey's jobs & abuses of the church - positives
although he plundered the Churches wealth to fund his lifestyle, extravagance was usual for dignitaries of the Church at this time, esp those ho held gov jobs too
was Henry who suggested Wolsey make himself Abbot of St Albans
Wolsey's abuses of the church
church funds paid for extravagant lifestyle
pluralism was unparalleled in English history - e.g. was both Archbishop of York & Bishop of Durham (1523-29), despite not setting foot in either area (absenteeism) - at one point held 7 diff church positions at same time
took jobs for money, doing none of spiritual work positions entailed - made himself Abbot of St Albans, richest monastery in Eng (despite not being a monk)
Gave bishoprics to non-residentItalian supporters in Rome e.g. Cardinal Campeggio made Bishop of Salisbury in 1524.
Wolsey's church reforms - successes
attempted to improve priests'education - formed Cardinal's College in Oxford (1525) & a grammar school in Ipswich
came up with reform ideas e.g. increasing no. of bishoprics
used legate powers to reformcorrupt monasteries e.g. the unruly abbey in Thame
Wolsey's church reforms - failures
made no serious attempt to make Church a better institution
milked organisation for everything he could get from it
one monastic reform became notorious when monks in Greenwich were imprisoned & excommunicated
Wolsey's successes in tackling heresy
banned Lutheran books in 1521
later arrested suspected heretics in 1526
Wolsey's failures in tackling heresy
critics argued he didn't care about spiritual matters or about what people really believed if they presented no threat to stability of the state
e.g. he ‘let off’ Hugh Latimer in 1525 for preaching againstCatholicpriests’ corruption and merely banned Thomas Bilney from preaching in 1527, after he’d campaigned against the worship of icons & saints.