EP's = lack of morninglight in winter means the pineal gland secrets melatonin for longer - has a knock-on effect on the production of serotonin in the brain - which has been linked to depressive symptoms.
Menstrual synchrony is evolutionarily advantageous - females would fall pregnant at the same time meaning new-borns could be cared for collectively. This increased chances of survival.
The validity of the results from McClintock's study are questioned - as they didn't control for extraneous factors like smoking, physical activity, and alcohol consumption.
This means that it's difficult to conclude that the pattern of synchronisation seen in Stern and McClintock's study - and doubts the influence of pheromones.
This raises doubts about whether they overstated the strength of the influence of pheromones as an exogenous zeitgeber which can entrain infradian rhythms.
Moreover, it was based on a small sample of 29 women (which limits the generalisability of findings), and relied on participant's self-report of the onset of their cycle.
Since phototherapy involves exposure to bright light to reset melatonin levels, this implies that melatonin and serotonin levels have little parts to play in the development of SAD - but that low Vitamin D levels have a more significant role.