Soverginity of the individual

Cards (8)

  • Agree
    Feminist views such as Mary Anne Warren on the rights of women to make decisions about their health/bodies as women reproductive rights
    e.g In Japan abortion is legal with mens approval
  • Agree
    Personal autonomy for those who are suffering and have no quality of life
    e.g Tony Nicklinson dies six days after losing 'right to die' case
  • Agree
    Uk law suicide act 2010 allows for individual autonomy in matters relating to their own life, including the end of their life
  • Disagree
    the autonomy of criminals needs to be interfered with to protect society e.g 19 children, 2 adults killed in Texas school rampage
  • Disagree
    If we have no absolute laws, this could lead to nihilism. Doystovesky "without god everything is permitted"
  • Disagree
    God has authority- not humans
    certain things are always wrong for christians
  • Disagree
    Individual choice cannot always take supreme authority since humans are infallible and are not always acting in a clear mindset e.g Hitler thought what he was doing was right
  • Disagree
    In the case of euthanasia many people may not be in the state to decide so somebody may have to on their behalf