Generalized Scheme for the Development of a Nutritional Deficiency (Gibson, 2005)
Depletion stages
Method
Depletion stages
Dietary inadequacy
Decreased level in reserve tissue store
Decreased level in body fluids
Decreased functional level in tissues
Decreased activity of nutrient-dependent enzyme or mRNA for some proteins
Functional changes
Clinical signs/symptoms
Anatomical signs
Biochemical Assessment
Measurement of a nutrient and its metabolite in blood, feces, urine, or blood which has a relationship to nutritional status
Biochemical Assessment
More objective and precise approach than the other methods
Can identify borderline nutritional condition prior to appearance of symptoms
Reveal marginal or acute deficiencies when clinical signs are normal since clinical signs usually occur only after prolonged inadequate intakes
Limitations of Biochemical Assessment
May not necessarily reflect presence of pathological lesion nor show health significance in relation to nutritional status
Affected by biological or technical factors (confounders) rather than nutrient status
May not always reflect total body nutrient content or tissue stores which is most sensitive to nutritional change
Interpretation of results are not always simple
Laboratory Methods are Used to Determine Deficiencies in
Serum protein particularly albumin level
Blood-forming nutrients – iron, folacin, vitamin B6, and vitamin B12
Water-soluble vitamins – thiamine, riboflavin, niacin, and vitamin C
Fat-soluble vitamins – A, D, E, K
Minerals – iron, iodine and other trace minerals
Lipids and glucose – cholesterol, triglycerides, various enzymes which are implicated in heart disease, diabetes, and other chronic diseases
Types of Biochemical Tests
Static Biochemical Tests
Functional Test
Static biochemical tests
Measure the level rather than the function of a nutrient
Provide information on the degree of deficiency of the particularly body pool sampled rather than the whole-body status
Measure either a nutrient in biological fluids or tissues or the urinary excretion rate of the nutrient or its metabolite
Static biochemical tests
Useful for identifying the second and third stages in the development of a nutritional deficiency when the tissue stores followed by the body fluids levels become gradually depleted of the nutrient(s)
Some static biochemical tests measure levels of the nutrient in biological fluids and tissues on the assumption that such tests reflect the total body nutrient content or the nutrient tissue store most sensitive to depletion
Show the change of nutrient concentration in any given specimen which is most sensitive to nutritional change
Functional tests
Functional physiological tests
Functional biochemical tests
Functional physiological tests
Assess the physiological performance of an individual in vivo such as immune competence, taste acuity, night blindness, muscle function, and work capacity
None of the tests are specific and must be interpreted along with biochemical measurements
Determine the changes in the activities of enzymes dependent on a specific nutrient or in the concentrations of specific blood components dependent on a given nutrient
Functional biochemical tests
Assess the consequences of the nutrient deficiency by measuring changes in the activities of a specific enzyme or in the concentrations of specific blood components dependent on a given nutrient
Potential Confounders
Subject characteristics
Health condition
Biological
Sampling errors
Method
Specimen
Measurement errors
Factors to Consider in Specimen Collection
Ease of data/sample collection
Sample storage and transport
Transportability and ruggedness of field equipment
Expertise available for collection and analysis
Equipment available and its maintenance
Culture and religious context
Costs (capital and recurring costs, training, personnel, maintenance of equipment
Commonly Used Specimen (1)
Venous blood
Capillary blood
Erythrocyte
Leucocyte
Commonly Used Specimen (2)
Breast milk
Sweat
Semen
Hair
Nails
Mucosal swab
Stool
Biopsy materials
Liver
Amniotic fluid
Urine
Readily available, and non-invasive
A normal renal function is a prerequisite when used as specimen to determine nutritional status
Analyses on fasting morning, casual, or 24-hr collections
24-hour urine is the most preferred as concentration of nutrient metabolite is not equally distributed throughout the day
Factors to Consider in Selection of Laboratory Methods for Nutritional Impact Evaluation
Nature of the intervention/program
Kind
Severity
Prevalence of nutritional problems in the population
Nutritional biomarkers
Biological measurements (e.g., in blood or urine) that are used to indicate normal biological processes, pathogenic processes, or pharmacologic responses to therapeutic intervention
Defined as biological characteristics that can be objectively measured and evaluated as indicators of normal biological or patho genic processes, or as responses to nutrition inter ventions
Can be measure ments based on biological tissues and fluids, on physio logical or behavioral functions, and more recently, on metabolic and genetic data that in turn influence health, well-being and risk of disease
Uses of nutritional biomarkers
Program managers and policymakers use population-level biomarkers for screening, surveillance, and monitoring and evaluation of interventions
Clinicians use biomarkers mainly for diagnosis, prognosis, and treatment; and researchers use biomarkers for any or all of these purposes based on their needs
Classification of nutritional biomarkers
Biomarkers of exposure
Biomarkers of status
Biomarkers of function
Biomarkers of exposure
Biomarkers of "exposure": Biomarkers of "status": body fluids (serum, erythro cytes, leuco cytes, urine, breast milk); tissues (hair, nails)
Biomarkers of function
Measure the extent of the functional con sequences of a nutrient deficiency: serve as early bio markers of subclinical deficiencies
Functional biochemical: enzyme stimulation assays; abnormal metabolites; DNA damage
Functional physio logical/behavioral": more directly related to health status or disease such as vision, growth, immune function, taste acuity, cognition, depression. These biomarkers impact on clinical and health outcomes
Biomarkers of exposure
Food or nutrient intakes; dietary patterns; sup ple ment usage
Can be based on direct measurements of nutrient intake using traditional dietary assessment methods, or indirect measurements using surrogate indicators termed "dietary bio markers"
Classification and properties of dietary biomarkers
Recovery biomarkers
Concentration biomarkers
Predictive biomarkers
Recovery biomarkers
Measure total excretion of marker over a defined time period
Excretion is a fixed proportion of intake with only negligible inter-individual variation
Best suited to measure absolute intake
Concentration biomarkers
Based solely on the con centration of the bio marker
Provide no infor mation on physio logical balance and excretion
Cannot be translated into absolute levels of intake
Positively correlated with intake, so can be used for ranking
Predictive biomarkers
Incomplete recovery
Stable and time-dependent, and a high correlation with intake
Used in medicine to predict who is likely to respond to therapy
Rank between con centration and recovery bio markers in terms of ability to estimate absolute intake
Biomarkers of status
Measure ments of concentrations of a nutrient in biological fluids or tissues, or the urinary excretion rate of a nutrient or its metabolite
Biopsy material most frequently used is whole blood or some fraction of blood
Other body fluids and tissues, less widely used, include urine, saliva, adipose tissue, breast milk, semen, amniotic fluid, hair, toenails, skin, and buccal mucosa
Biomarkers of function
Measure the extent of the functional con sequences of a nutrient deficiency
Functional biochemical: enzyme stimulation assays; abnormal metabolites; DNA damage
Functional physio logical/behavioral": more directly related to health status or disease such as vision, growth, immune function, taste acuity, cognition, depression. These biomarkers impact on clinical and health outcomes
Biomarkers of function
Measure the extent of the functional consequences of a nutrient deficiency
Have greater biological significance than static biomarkers
Some are used as substitutes for chronic disease outcomes (surrogate biomarkers)
Types of functional biomarkers
Functional biochemical
Functional physiological/behavioral
Functional biochemical biomarkers
Serve as early biomarkers of subclinical deficiencies
Measure abnormal metabolic products in blood/urine from nutrient-dependent enzyme deficiency
Measure reduced activity of nutrient-dependent enzymes
Functional biochemical biomarkers
Urinary excretion of xanthurenic acid, formiminoglutamic acid (FIGLU), and methylmalonic acid for vitamin B6 and B12 deficiency
Erythrocyte glutathione reductase activity for riboflavin
Erythrocyte transketolase activity for thiamin
Erythrocyte glutamic oxaloacetic transaminase for vitamin B6
Whole blood hemoglobin for iron
Thyroglobulin for iodine
Retinol-binding protein for vitamin A
Holo transcobalamin for vitamin B12
Functional physiological and behavioral biomarkers
Lymphocyte proliferation for protein-energy, zinc, and iron
Relative Dose Response: load test for vitamin A
CobaSorb test: load test for vitamin B12 absorption
Delayed-type hypersensitivity for protein-energy malnutrition
Dark adaptation/vision at low intensity for vitamin A
Taste acuity for zinc
Handgrip strength for lower-body strength
Growth velocity for protein-energy, zinc, etc.
Cognitive performance for iron, iodine, vitamin D, folate, and vitamin B12
Motor development for micronutrients
Depression for folate and zinc
Biomarkers should be selected with care, and their limitations under conditions of health, inflammation, genetic and disease states understood
Biomarkers are affected by non-biological sources of variation arising from specimen collection and storage, seasonality, time of day, contamination, stability, and laboratory quality assurance
Both biological and non-biological sources of variation will impact the validity, precision, accuracy, specificity, sensitivity, and predictive value of the biomarker
Personnel should use calibrated equipment and standardized, validated techniques which are continuously monitored by appropriate quality-control procedures
Factors affecting choice of nutritional biomarkers