Cards (18)

  • What is the form?
    Commemorative architecture - one of the branches within the IWM museums
  • When did it open?
    2002
  • What is the style?
    Deconstructivism = jutting angles + aluminium cladding
  • Where is it located?
    Trafford Park, Manchester
  • What is so special about the area?
    It was an important location for the manufacturing of military material = main target in the Manchester Blitz during WW2
  • Who is the architect?
    Daniel Libeskind
  • What is the inspiration for the framework?
    Broken teapot fragments, Libeskind sealed a round teapot in a plastic bag and dropped it out of the 4th floor windows of Berlin Studio.
  • What do the 3 interlocking shards represent?
    Different conflict locations = Air, Earth and Water
  • Give the critical text
    "Sense of loss" (Giles Worsley) - in conclusion
  • Give a point about the entrance within the Air Shard
    Point: Functions as the museum’s entrance
    Reasoning: boasting small, “bunker-like” architecture through the simple square-framing which contrasts to tradition.
    Effect: Create an initial feeling of disorientation.
  • Give a point about the tower within the Air Shard
    Point: Once entered, guided along a pathway to the main part of the Air Shard = is an empty and hollow 55m tall tower.
    Effect: Allowing visitor to be exposed to the elements within space that is neither inside nor outside, with unglazed slits piercing the walls.
  • Give a point about the zinc clad lift + continue describing the tower
    Point: Can ride a zinc clad lift up the tower to a 29m high viewing platform. However, the walls are angled unnervingly at 4.5 degrees off centre.
    Effect: Highlights Libeskind continual aim to disorientate and confuse the visitor.
  • Give a point regarding the Earth shard's function
    Point: Acts as the museum’s first-floor gallery, where permanent exhibitions are housed.
  • Give a point about the features of the Earth shard
    Point (1): No natural light inside the main exhibition space and the effect of the cuts across the ceiling and the recessed lighting
    Effect (1): Emulate searchlights or even tracer bullets
    Point (2): Uses an environmentally friendly cooling system that alters the temperature at different points.
    Point (2): Intensify the visitor’s experiences
  • Give a point about The Big Picture Show within the Earth shard
    Point: The Big Picture Show (which is a series of filmic installations) occurs for 10 minutes every hour on the 27 ft high walls.

    Effect: Grabs the visitor’s attention, guiding them to indulge on an impactful experience, causing the visitor to have a focused physical and emotional response. + installation contrasts to the traditional museum arrangements = allowing visitor to understand the effects of conflict, highlighting Libeskind conforms to storytelling atmosphere within the first – floor gallery.
  • Give a point about the Water shard's "wave-like" forms, "ferry-like" windows and uneven walls/floorplan.
    Point (1): Undulates away from the building, arcing upward to recall the waves of the sea.
    Reasoning (1): “wake-like” forms help to generate a viewing platform for individuals to look onto the canal below.
    Point (2): Includes “ferry-like” windows
    Reasoning: (2): Reminiscent to the cargo liners that travelled the Manchester Ship Canal
    Point (3): Contains uneven walls/floorplan.
    Reasoning: Unsettle the visitor, reminding them of the purpose
  • Give a point about the other amenities the Water shard offers its visitors
    Point: Also includes a restaurant, café and provides deck performance space as well.
  • Give the conclusion point
    Aimed visitors to feel the unsettling nature of war throughout all 3 shards presented.