AO3: Virtual

Cards (4)

  • Limitation: Lack of support for reduced cues
    What? Non-verbal cues different not absent
    Who? Walther and Tidwell - Other cues (timing/style of messages); acronyms or emojis substitute for facial expressions
    Why? Virtual relationships just as personal
  • Limitation: Lack of support for hyperpersonal model
    What? Challenging evidence
    Who? Ruppel - meta-analysis (25 studies); self-reports found frequency, breadth and depth of self-disclosures greater in face-to-face - experimental studies showed no difference
    Why? Contradictory
  • Counterpoint: Lack of support for hyperpersonal model
    What? Some evidence
    Who? Whitty and Joinson - online discussions tend to be hyperhonest and self-presentation hyperdishonest
    Why? Supports hyperhonesty and hyperdishonesty
  • Strength: Support for absence of gating
    What? Shy, lonely and socially anxious people find virtual relationships valuable
    Who? McKenna and Bargh - Able to express 'true selves'; 71% of relationships survived at least 2 years
    Why? Shy people benefit online