What is the evaluation of the fight or flight response?
- The 'tend and befriend response'
. Taylor (2000) suggests that for females, behavioural responses to stress are more characterised by a pattern of tend and befriend than fight or flight.
. This involves protecting themselves and their young through nurturing behaviours (tending) and forming protective alliances with other women (befriending)
. Women may have a completely different system for coping with stress because their responses evolved in the context of being a primary caregiver of their children. Fleeing too readily at any sign of danger would put a female's offspring at risk.
-Negative consequences of the fight or flight response
. The problem for modern humans is when the stress response is repeatedly activated.
. Although cortisol can give a burst of energy, too much cortisol suppresses the immune response, shutting down the very process that fights infection.
. This means the stress response can actually harm the body.
-Fight or flight does not tell the whole story
. Gray (1988) argues that the first phase of reaction to a threat is not fight or flight but to avoid confrontation.
. Prior to responding with attacking or running away animals display a 'freeze response'. This is a response where the animal is hyper-vigilant.
. The advantages for humans is it makes them look for new information to make the best response for the threat.
-Von Dawans et al (2012) challenged the view that men use fight or flight and women respond with tend and befriend. They found that acute stress can actually lead to greater cooperative and friendly behaviour, even in men. This could explain the human connection that happens during times of crises such as 9/11 terrorist attacks in New York.