LECTURE 2 - Negligence (Part One)

Cards (12)

  • Negligence
    A tort law concept that deals with situations where someone fails to exercise a reasonable standard of care, resulting in harm to another person
  • Law must find a balance between compensating for carelessness and ensuring that defendants are not exposed to "a liability in an indeterminate amount for an indeterminate time to an indeterminate class"
  • Donoghue v Stevenson
    Established the "duty to not injure neighbour" - manufacturers had a duty of care to the ultimate consumers of their products
  • Donoghue v Stevenson: '"You must take reasonable care to avoids acts or omissions which you can reasonably foresee would be likely to injury your neighbour"'
  • The test for whether there is liability for negligence has evolved since Donoghue v Stevenson
  • Elements of Negligence (the law today)
    • A duty of care
    • Breach of the duty of care
    • Harm
    • Remoteness
  • Duty of care
    • Factors relevant: 1) Relationship/proximity between parties, 2) Presence/absence of policy factors
  • Possible Policy Factors
    • Fairness and reasonableness
    • Societal impact
    • Economic impact
    • Encouragement of socially desirable activities
    • Avoiding opening "floodgates" of litigation
    • Consistency/overlap with other laws
  • Breach of duty of care
    Defendant has failed to exercise the standard of care appropriate in the circumstances
  • Factors relevant to standard of care
    • Ordinary reasonable person in that position
    • Higher standard if person holds themselves out as having expertise
    • Degree of risk or harm
    • Cost of neutralizing the risk
    • Common practice of the trade or profession
  • Harm
    • Plaintiff must show: 1) Actual loss or harm, 2) Caused by defendant's breach of duty
  • Remoteness of Harm
    A person will not be liable for losses that are "too remote"/removed from the defendant. Liability only extends to type of damage which a reasonable person would have foreseen.