Reject the view that sociology is a science due to the lack of realism in scientific experiments
Science experiments
Typically conducted in artificial settings such as laboratories
Lack generalisation to conditions outside of the lab setting
May be subject to the Hawthorne effect, whereby participants alter their behaviour as they are aware their behaviours are being studied
Weber's view
We should study human behaviours in terms of the meaning they attach to their actions
Interpretivist view
Understanding the subjective meanings attached to behaviours is better as people in society differ, and there is no universal meaning of human behaviour
Verstehen
To fully understand one's point of view, we must view life from their eyes or in other words put ourselves into other people's shoes
Interpretivist approach
Qualitative
Higher level of validity is more likely to come about, as researchers gain more in-depth material about what they are investigating so we can trust the results gathered from a study
Popper's view
For a theory to be scientific, we must attempt to prove it as wrong (falsify it)
For sociology to be accepted as a science via falsification, then sociological theories would have to propose a testable hypothesis (every theory/statement outlined must be testable)
The Marxist concept of false class consciousness is rejected as it cannot be tested and thus, cannot be falsified
Popper's theory
We should use a deductive method, meaning that we start with a theory and test evidence against it, if none of the evidence put forth contradicts the existing theory, the theory would then be accepted as a science
Positivist view
An inductive method should be used, whereby we examine data and build a theory on the basis of this, and finally defend the theory with evidence that strengthens it
By providing evidence in support of a theory we will never know if any other knowledge strays away from it, Popper argues, that truth is only temporary, and knowledge is changeable
Paradigm shift
If there is overwhelming evidence which contradicts the pre-existing paradigm, a paradigm shift takes place
If paradigm shifts are accurate, then objectivity, as suggested by positivists, are undermined, thus contradicting the statement that sociology can be a science