Why did Henry "The Young King" rebel against his father Henry II?
His father refused agreement to hand him the throne to rule England, Normandy or Anjou on his own in 1173 (since he's eldest) and later in 1182 (with Geoffrey and Philip II) when he had no land whereas his brothers did
Why did Richard rebel against his father Henry II?
- Henry's favouritism for John
- Tried to take away Richard's possession of Aquitaine and give it to John which he refused to give away (the position of Duke of Aquitaine)
- He rebelled later in 1189, joining forces with Phillip II which led to a successful attack on Henry's lands and forced Henry II to sign a humiliating peace treaty
-- He's a failure - e.g. Loss of Normandy in 1204, picking favourites with the barons
-- Created many problems for himself (that were possibly easy to fix) - e.g. Marriage to Isabella of Angouleme, use of his nephew Arthur, Magna Carter, quarrel with Pope and barons etc.
-- He was a poor soldier and useless at managing the barons, which was his most important job - e.g. Baron's war, Battle of Bouvines (he was not present)
-- He was unlucky who ruled England during a difficult time and faced an impossible task to keep the Angevin Empire together with the lack of resources e.g. money after Richard's ransom
-- He faced an experienced, dangerous and skilful opponent (Phillip II)
-- King who neglected his kingdom and wasted resources abroad on crusades (only had been in England for about 6 months in his 10 month reign)
-- Obsessed with war and his actions of crusade were brutal and stupid (4 battles - Third Crusade, Battle of Jaffa, Acre and Arsuf. Also died during battle in France by a crossbow wound)