4. Processes that overlap search areas are candidates
5. If no one process meets all requirements, stack processes
Design requirements
Material, shape, size, minimum section, precision, and finish
Sequence of process selection
1. List design requirements
2. Plot requirements on process charts
3. Identify search areas
4. Processes that overlap search areas are candidates
5. If no one process meets all requirements, stack processes
The process selection charts inputs are design requirements; the output is a ranked short-list of processes capable of meeting design requirements
Stacking processes
Casting followed by machining (to meet the tolerance specification on one surface, for instance); or powder methods followed by grinding
The sequence of process selection using process selection charts is the input of design requirements, and the output is a ranked short-list of processes capable of meeting design requirements
Candidates
Processes that overlap the search areas and are capable of making the component to its design specification
If no one process meets all the design requirements, then processes have to be "stacked"
Forming
The process of shaping a material into a desired form
Fan for vacuum cleaners
Designed to be cheap, quiet, and efficient
The key to minimizing process costs is to form the fan to its final shape in a single operation (net-shape forming)
Leaving only the central hub to be machined to fit the shaft
The selection of a single process that can meet the specifications on precision and tolerance, avoiding the need for machining or finishing of the disk or blades
Fan
Blades made of nylon, require low roughness and a certain precision, produced in large numbers for use in electric vacuum cleaners
Design requirements for the fan
Material (nylon)
Radius (60mm)
Number of blades (20)
Blade thickness (4mm)
Weight (0.1-0.2kg)
Shape (3D solid)
Precision (0.5mm)
Surface roughness (1mm)
Production run (10,000)
The design requirements for the fan are summarized in Table 1
The next step is to identify the processes that can meet these design requirements
Material choice for the fan
Nylon (using material selection charts)
Pumping rate of a fan
Determined by its radius and rate of revolution
The designer calculates the need for a fan of radius 60mm, with 20 profiled blades of average thickness 4 mm
Volume of material in the fan
Roughly, a weight in the range 0.1 - 0.2 kg
Fan
Complex shape, though its high symmetry simplifies it somewhat
Classified as 3D solid
Precision (tolerances)
0.5mm
Surface roughness
1 mm
Production run of 10,000 fans
The design requirements are summarized in Table 1
Processes that can meet the design requirements
1. Screening on mass and section thickness
2. Constraints on tolerance and roughness
3. Planned batch size of 10,000
The process-shape compatibility matrix of the three case studies is a helpful tool in narrowing the choice, suggesting alternatives, and providing a background against which a final selection can be made
Weight of the fan
0.1 - 0.2 kg
Section thickness of the fan
4 mm
Tolerance (Precision)
0.5mm
Fan production quantity = 10,000 fans
Surface Roughness
Less than 1 mm
The table shows the candidate processes that were screened using the process selection charts, where some processes were eliminated for not meeting all the constraints, leaving only the processes that met all the requirements
The final process selection depends on the process that can produce the fan at the lowest cost, where the processes are ranked from lowest to highest cost
A pressure vessel is required for a hot-isostatic press or HIP
Pressure vessels
Designed to yield or leak before they break
Small pressure vessels are usually designed to allow general yield at a pressure still too low to cause any crack the vessel may contain to propagate
Large pressure vessels are always made of steel
A model steam engine is made of copper, even though it is more expensive, because of its greater resistance to corrosion
Corrosion rates do not scale with size, so a 0.1mm loss through corrosion is not serious in a 10mm thick pressure vessel, but becomes a concern in a 1mm thick vessel
Pressure vessels still occasionally fail
Small pressure vessels
Designed to allow general yield at a pressure still too low to cause any crack the vessel may contain to propagate
Distortion caused by yielding is easy to detect and the pressure can be released safely