Interactionist Approach in Explaining and Treating SZ

Cards (20)

  • What does the diathesis-stress model propose about schizophrenia (SZ)?
    It results from psychological and biological influences
  • How do symptoms of SZ relate to stressors and biological vulnerability?
    Symptoms worsen with stressors and biological vulnerability
  • Why do not all genetically predisposed individuals develop SZ?
    Because environmental factors also play a role
  • What is the genetic component of diathesis in SZ?
    It refers to genetic vulnerability to the disorder
  • What did Tienari et al find regarding identical twins and SZ?
    Identical twins have a higher risk than siblings
  • What does the disconcordance among identical twins suggest?
    Environmental factors influence the development of SZ
  • What modern factors are included in the understanding of diathesis?
    Factors beyond genetics, including trauma
  • What does Read's neurodevelopmental model propose?
    Early trauma alters brain development, increasing vulnerability
  • What types of stressful life events can trigger SZ?
    Childhood trauma and urban living stresses
  • What did Varese et al find about children and trauma?
    Children with severe trauma are three times more likely to develop SZ
  • How does the level of trauma relate to the risk of developing SZ?
    Higher trauma levels increase the risk of SZ
  • What is a modern understanding of stress in relation to SZ?
    Anything that triggers symptoms of SZ
  • What recent research has focused on as a trigger for SZ?
    Cannabis use
  • Why is cannabis considered a stressor for SZ?
    It increases SZ risk by up to seven times
  • How does cannabis interfere with the risk of SZ?
    It interferes with the dopamine system
  • How do diathesis and stress interact to lead to SZ?
    • Minor stressors can trigger SZ in highly vulnerable individuals
    • Major stressors can trigger SZ in those with low vulnerability
    • This suggests an additive relationship between diathesis and stress
  • What does the additive nature of diathesis and stress imply?
    They combine to produce the disorder
  • Diathesis-Stress Model AO3 - Real world application

    • Tarrier et al - patients allocated to one of three conditions, where the last control group received no treatment and the first two groups received a combination of psychological and biological treatments
    • After an 18 month follow-up, "there were significant advantages for CBT and supportive counseling over TAU alone on symptom measures, no group difference was seen for relapse or re-hospitalisation”
    • Adjunctive psychological treatments can have a beneficial long-term effect on symptom reduction
  • Diathesis-Stress Model AO3 - Over-simplistic

    • Most diathesis-stress models emphasise ‘vulnerability’ in terms of genetic influences alone
    • Ex. Ripke et al - over 108 candidate genes, each slightly increasing the risk of SZ, and so there is no single 'schizogene'
    • Stress can come in many forms apart from the schizophrenogenic mother or dysfunctional parenting - high levels of expressed emotion, childhood trauma (Read et al) and the excessive use of cannabis (Houston et al)
    • Therefore, the diathesis is not exclusively biological, nor is the stressor exclusively psychological.
  • Diathesis-Stress Model AO3 - Support for vulnerability 

    • Tienari et al - used research from mothers and adoptees who suffered from SZ and compared these findings to a neurotypical group adopted across the same period
    • Adoptive parents - high levels of critics, hostility and low levels of empathy were strongly associated with the development of SZ but only in the genetic risk group
    • Therefore, this provides strong support for the diathesis-stress model because the findings demonstrate that a single diathesis is not enough to trigger the development of SZ