PEELs for explanations of OCD
1) Strength = good supporting evidence
Lewis - 37% concordance rate of OCD if a parent has OCD, 21% if a sibling has it
Nestadt - 68% concordance rate between MZ twins, 31% for DZ twins
SSRIs work in treatment of OCD b/c they increase levels of seratonin
Shows some involvement of biology
2) Weakness = Biological explanations tell us little about the causes of OCD
No one system has been found that always plays a role in OCD, things happening in the brain could be a result of OCD, rather than causing it
Genes play a role, but due to OCD being polygenetic - no one specific gene, genes often require trigger (Diathesis-stress)
Biologically reductionist only considers biological factors
3) Weakness = ignore environmental factors
Diasthesis-stress model explains how genes create vulnerability but not a guarentee, only 68& concordance in MZ twins despite identical genes
Cromer et al - Over half of the OCD patients in their sample had a notable traumatic event in their past - OCD was more severe in those with more than one trauma
More holistic approach needed