what was Keen et al. research into anger management programmes?
- studied youth offenders (17-21 year olds) who took part in the National Anger Management Package
- offenders had a 8 two hour sessions, the first 7 over a three week period and one session a month later
- found initially offenders did not take the course seriously + forgot important elements for programme e.g. diary
- generally led to positive outcomes : offenders reported increased awareness of their anger management problems + increased capacity to exercise self control
how does Blackburn criticise long term effects of anger management programmes?
- it may not lead to lowered recidivism rates
- found that whilst anger management did have a positive effect on the behaviour of offenders in the short term, it did not actually reduce their reoffending rates long term
- counteracts the claim that they may be most effective long term way of dealing with offending behaviour
how does anger management programmes have long term effects?
- effects may last longer than that of behaviour modification in custody
- anger management aims to tackle the underlying cognitive causes of offending such as hostile attribution bias, rather than just reducing the instance of undesirable behaviour
- important as they are more likely to lead to a more permanent change in offending behaviour leading to more positive outcomes
- for example, in order to be implemented in custody they require the service of highly trained specialists for a long period of time who are used to dealing with violent offenders
- prison service is highly under funded and is unlikely to be able to invest in anger management programmes, particularly when the evidence for its utility is mixed
- so they are not a realistic way for most prisons to effectively deal with offending behaviour so usefulness is limited
- BUT if they reduce recidivism rates they will be cheaper in the long term
how does Ireland have supportive evidence for anger management programmes?
- found that when comparing offenders who took part in the National Anger Management Package programme with a non treatment control group that the offenders showed significantly more improvement : 92% improved on at least one measure of behaviour compared to 48% of controls
- improves the validity in programmes so can be more confident in the effectiveness